Polly Plummer: A Comprehensive Character Analysis from The Chronicles of Narnia

Introduction

Polly Plummer is a pivotal and enduring character in C.S. Lewis’s renowned fantasy series, The Chronicles of Narnia. She appears prominently in two of the seven books: The Magician’s Nephew and The Last Battle. Introduced in The Magician’s Nephew, which is the first book in the internal chronology of Narnia, Polly is an 11-year-old girl living in London in 1900. Her character is defined by her practicality, sensibility, and strong moral compass, which counterbalance the more impulsive and adventurous nature of her friend Digory Kirke.

Polly’s significance extends beyond her role in the narrative; she represents a strong and independent female character in a period when such portrayals were less common. Her friendship with Digory and her interactions with other characters contribute to the rich tapestry of themes and symbolism that are central to The Chronicles of Narnia. This article will delve into Polly’s backstory, her role in the story, character analysis, themes and symbolism, cultural impact, critical reception, and her lasting legacy.

Role in the Story

Polly’s journey begins in The Magician’s Nephew, where she befriends Digory Kirke, who is staying with his aunt in the same row of terrace houses as Polly. The two children often explore the attics of their connected houses, leading them to accidentally discover the forbidden study of Digory’s Uncle Andrew. Here, they encounter magical rings that transport them to other worlds, including the dying world of Charn and the newly created world of Narnia.

In Charn, Polly and Digory release Jadis, the future White Witch, who follows them back to London and eventually to Narnia. Polly’s practical caution and concern for safety are crucial as they navigate these dangerous and unfamiliar worlds. She advises against certain actions, such as ringing the bell in Charn, and is instrumental in helping Digory retrieve a magical apple to heal his mother’s illness ^[1][4].

In The Last Battle, Polly appears as an adult, 60 years old, and remains in close contact with the other British "friends of Narnia." She is present when King Tirian of Narnia seeks their help and later dies in a railway accident, only to be transported to Aslan’s country where she and Digory are restored to their youth and recognized as royalty ^[1].

Character Analysis

Polly is characterized by her sensibility, reliability, and strong moral foundation. She is a practical and logical individual who often serves as a grounding influence on Digory’s more fanciful and impulsive nature. Her friendship with Digory is complex, built on a mix of sympathy, tolerance, and mutual respect. Polly is not afraid to challenge Digory when he makes mistakes and is a constant source of emotional and moral support ^[2][4].

Despite her cautious approach, Polly is brave and feisty, often proving to be smarter and more courageous than Digory in critical situations. Her character defies the stereotypes of her time, presenting a strong and equal female counterpart to Digory’s adventures ^[5].

Polly’s personality is also marked by her compassion and kindness. She feels deeply for others, such as the cart horse and Digory’s ailing mother, and is quick to offer comfort and support. Her distrust of new people and situations, particularly evident in her interactions with Uncle Andrew and Jadis, underscores her cautious and practical nature ^[4].

Themes and Symbolism

Polly embodies several key themes in The Chronicles of Narnia. Her character represents the importance of caution, practicality, and moral integrity. Her relationship with Digory highlights the value of friendship and mutual support, as well as the balance between impulsive action and careful consideration.

Polly’s contrast with Jadis, the last Queen of Charn, is particularly symbolic. While Jadis represents power-lust and destruction, Polly stands for compassion, kindness, and the protection of others. This dichotomy underscores the broader themes of good vs. evil and the consequences of one’s actions ^[2].

Polly’s journey also symbolizes personal growth and the discovery of one’s place in the world. Her initial fear and uncertainty in new worlds give way to a sense of belonging and purpose, especially in the presence of Aslan. This transformation reflects the broader narrative of The Chronicles of Narnia, which often explores themes of identity, faith, and the human condition ^[1][4].

Cultural Impact

Polly Plummer has had a significant cultural impact since her introduction in The Magician’s Nephew. She is one of the few strong and independent female characters in children’s literature of her time, making her a role model for young readers. Her portrayal challenges traditional gender roles and stereotypes, contributing to a broader cultural shift towards more inclusive and diverse representations in literature.

In adaptations and spin-offs of The Chronicles of Narnia, Polly has been portrayed in various ways, but her core character traits have remained consistent. Her influence can be seen in other works of fantasy literature, where strong and practical female characters have become more prevalent.

Critical Reception

Critics and audiences have generally praised Polly’s character for her strength, sensibility, and moral integrity. Her dynamic with Digory has been particularly noted for its complexity and depth, adding a rich layer to the narrative of The Magician’s Nephew.

Some critics have highlighted the contrast between Polly and other female characters in the series, such as Susan Pevensie, who is often criticized for her exclusion from the final battle. Polly’s inclusion and significant role in the story have been seen as a positive aspect of Lewis’s writing, showcasing his ability to create well-rounded and meaningful female characters ^[3].

Legacy

Polly Plummer’s legacy is that of a enduring and influential character in fantasy literature. Her portrayal as a strong, practical, and compassionate individual has inspired countless readers and writers. Her role in The Chronicles of Narnia continues to be celebrated for its depth and complexity, making her one of the most memorable characters in the series.

In contemporary discussions, Polly’s character remains relevant as a symbol of female empowerment and the importance of balanced decision-making. Her friendship with Digory serves as a model for healthy and supportive relationships, and her moral compass continues to guide readers through the complexities of the narrative.